This was scanned from the edition and mechanically checked against a commercial copy of the text from CDROM. Differences were corrected against the paper edition. The text itself is thus a highly accurate rendition.
A Journal of Mormon Scripture 5 Review of Rick Grunder. Discovering parallels is inherently an act of comparison. Through comparison, parallels have been introduced frequently as proof or evidence of different issues within Mormon studies. Despite this frequency, very few investigations provide a theoretical or methodological framework by which the parallels themselves can be evaluated.
This problem is not new to the field of Mormon studies but has in the past plagued literary studies more generally.
In Part One, this review essay discusses present and past approaches dealing with the ways in which parallels have been The charges against socrates essay and valued in acts of literary comparison, uncovering the various difficulties associated with unsorted parallels as well as discussing the underlying motivations for these comparisons.
In using a consistent methodology to value these parallels, this essay suggests a way to address the historical concerns associated with using parallels to explain both texts and Mormonism as an historical religious movement.
First I look at the problem of parallels. This context provides a useful starting point to examine the content of Mormon Parallels. I will include some discussion of the intentions behind such a comparison and how these comparisons have been used in a polemic against the faith of the Saints.
I will also reference discussions critical of the use of parallels and more recent attempts to rehabilitate the practice.
I begin in Part One with a discussion of problematic assumptions in comparisons, and then in Part Two I turn to the flawed results of their use. My essay is an examination of the perils of what has been called parallelomania. Grunder is aware of this term see p. But comparison is not a new endeavor, either for authors and their texts or for those studying religions.
James Hanges has argued that the comparative choice is often made because the.
This is frequently the case when religion provides the backdrop against which the comparative choices are to be portrayed. The theoretical underpinning of this kind of comparison is the assumption that groups come into being because of the genius of a single individual—groups follow and preserve the teachings of extraordinary leaders.
And these comparisons are not just limited to the individual; they expand their reach to include the teachings of founder figures as they have been preserved by their followers. In surprising depth and degree, much of what Mormonism presents as if it were its own, actually flourished at various levels of society before Joseph Smith declared it.
Grunder makes comparisons involving Joseph Smith that fit into the theological backdrop of Mormonism.
Arthur Marmorstein concluded his study by claiming that Jesus said nothing new. I include this material for two major reasons.
First, I wish to illustrate by example the idea of a history of the comparative method 7 used by Grunder. Whether this application is enlightening or misleading, however, will be shown to be an entirely separate question.
In this particular case, it is the person and the movement that make these comparisons seem both interesting and relevant. Yet, the process of identifying similarities in this way can be done for any person in any milieu — including even Grunder.Thanks for a very thoughtful paper.
Here is an additional thought to supplement it. In regard to proper names, and specifically to the name Cumorah, according to David Whitmer Joseph Smith upon encountering unfamiliar names and words in the translation/dictation process would spell them out.
Euthyphro (/ ˈ juː θ ɪ f r oʊ /; Ancient Greek: Εὐθύφρων, translit. Euthyphrōn; c.
– BC), by Plato, is a Socratic dialogue whose events occur in the weeks before the trial of Socrates ( BC), between Socrates and Euthyphro. The dialogue covers subjects such as the meaning of piety and justice.
- The Unjust Death of Socrates The question of why Socrates was executed and if he deserved the charges put against him has been asked by historians for centuries. Socrates has a unique position in the history of philosophy. On one hand he is the most influential on another he is the least known.
About the online edition. This was scanned from the edition and mechanically checked against a commercial copy of the text from CDROM.
Differences were corrected against the paper edition. Printed from iridis-photo-restoration.com On the Trial of Jesus.
The purpose of this essay is to provide an overview of the many issues and questions. One of the main charges against Socrates revolved around the fact that he was a natural philosopher This was so Essay Socrates and the Apology and 90,+ .